Porter Airlines Review: Is It Worth It?

I’ve heard a lot of hype around Porter Airlines as a new challenger airline in the Canadian aviation space. A new airline is always welcome in a country that is sorely lacking in competition. Furthermore, with the recent strikes and near-strikes from Air Canada and WestJet disrupting services or threatening to disrupt services, there are many reasons to consider Porter Airlines.

For those unaware, Porter Airlines is aiming to disrupt the market by offering a lot of the premium comforts that are lacking in WestJet and Air Canada’s economy offerings. For example, their planes are set up entirely as 2-2 seating arrangements, and they offer complimentary WiFi and complimentary beverages, including alcoholic beverages, on every flight.   

I was intrigued and excited to see what Porter could offer as an alternative airline. Read on for my experience.

Booking Porter Airlines

Economy ClassAircraftRouteFlight Duration
PD 378Embraer E195-E2Edmonton to Montreal4 Hours 3 Minutes

I was looking to fly to Montreal at the end of September 2024 for a quick long weekend getaway trip with my significant other. Air Canada, WestJet, and Porter all fly direct nonstop between YEG and YUL. However, given the impending strike with Air Canada pilots, and given I wanted to arrive at my destination on time, Porter Airlines was a pretty obvious choice of the three.   

The Porter flights were actually all very reasonable cost-wise.  Even though we only booked about a month in advance, we only paid $313.86 CAD for two people for the PorterClassic Standard fare (the lowest of Porter’s fares, nonrefundable and changeable for a fee).

porter airlines receipt summary for cost yeg yul

If you are bringing baggage, read up on Porter Airlines baggage fees before booking.

Interestingly, flying back on a holiday Monday showed massively inflated costs in excess of $700 for two people, while WestJet was only $342.47 for a Member Exclusive fare. Thus we only booked Porter as a one-way trip and opted to take our chances flying WestJet home to save nearly $400.

porter airlines porter reserve mistake fare 500

Curiously, I initially noticed a Porter Reserve Navigate Fare for only $532 for two people which was cheaper than the Classic Standard fare. This must have been a mispricing but unfortunately, I didn’t jump on it fast enough and it was soon gone.

Seat Selection

As seats on Porter Airlines are already in 2-2 arrangement I didn’t bother with seat selection. Unlike the new WestJet Ultra basic fare, itineraries booked on Porter will automatically have couples seated together. So unless you’re upgrading to a larger-sized seat, the seat selection fees are just a cash grab.

We were assigned seats 30C and 30D at check-in.

Ground Experience

There was little to report on regarding the boarding and gate process with my Porter flight, which is how I like it to be. We began boarding right on time. The plane was boarded back to front. We departed on time. Etcetera. 

For an indication of what you can expect with Porter regarding flight delays and cancellations, I find CTA complaints to be a decent proxy metric. Optimistically, at the time of writing, Porter has the lowest number of complaints per 100 flights:

Canadian Transportation Agency cumulative average of complaints per 100 flights March 2024. Porter is amongst the best at 1.4.

Porter has only 1.4. On the other hand, Air Canada and WestJet have 5.2 and 6.2, respectively. Meanwhile, Flair has a staggering 15.6.

In-Flight Experience

Seat 

Throughout the cabin, the Porter Airlines Classic seats were a homogenous, muted grey color. It didn’t have a premium aesthetic, but I thought it looked quite sharp nonetheless. 

Porter Airlines Classic fare seats.

I have to say that these seats were less than comfortable. The seats were narrow and offered little legroom, and this is coming from an average-height person (5’10”). I think anyone over 6 feet or on the heavier side would be quite dissatisfied.

Porter Airlines Classic fare seat legroom with 30" of pitch.

We were flying an Embraer E195 which, according to Seatmaps.com has 30” of pitch in regular economy seats. Some other airplanes you might fly on WestJet or Air Canada economy may have 31-33” of pitch, but other planes are comparable with 30-31”. For some reason, on Porter it felt like less room than I’d experienced on my last economy flights. But perhaps I am just out of touch or suffering from recency bias…

Image credit: Seatmaps.com

In any case, I think it’s worth paying for an exit row or extra legroom seat if you can afford to. Like other airlines, you can upgrade at the time of check-in. For this flight, it was around $60 per seat but there weren’t two side-by-side seats for us to nab. I honestly also wanted to experience the basic version of Porter for the sake of this review. 

The tray tables were predictably minimal but well designed and could be configured just for drinks in the ½ configuration or the fully deployed configuration for meals.

Of note, there was only a single 120V electrical outlet for each seat to plug devices into, no USB or USB-C unfortunately.

Food, Menu, & Service

One of Porter’s main marketing points is its complimentary beverages, including alcoholic beverages, and ‘premium’ complimentary snacks. 

While it’s certainly a nice touch, the addition of a $5 can of beer and a $2 snack to your flight should be inconsequential to anyone’s decision on which carrier they fly. 

For my choices, I had Beau’s Craft Beer and a milk chocolate shortbread cookie. Apparently, Porter also offers Hardbite kettle chips although this wasn’t offered to us on our flight.

porter airlines snack and beer

For other Porter flights over 2.5 hours in length, there are fresh in-flight meals available. These are complimentary for PorterReserve fares and a la carte for PorterClassic fares. 

I was a little jealous of Porter Reserve passengers. The food boxes looked quite tasty. Although I didn’t partake, the full PorterCafe menu is displayed below.

As for other beverages on offer, the first of the two in-flight services didn’t have any hot beverages available, which was disappointing. The service was rather inefficient, although that is typical of Canadian and North American airlines.

On the second service, I had a cup of coffee, provided by Saint Henri, a Montreal micro-roaster. I must say, it was one of the worst cups of coffee I’ve ever had on an airplane. Although it may be the fault of the flight attendants and not a quality issue. The coffee was so watered down it was almost undrinkable. Almost…

Entertainment

The WiFi didn’t want to work at first, but eventually, I was able to access it. It was simple enough to set up and there was a large instruction pamphlet in the seat as well as instructions on the second page of the meal menu. 

porter airlines free wifi connection instructions

The WiFi was provided by ViaSat. While it was complimentary for all passengers, you did need to be signed in to a VIPorter account. Otherwise, you would have to watch an ad every 30 minutes.

I found the WiFi to be quite slow. It was difficult to stream things like YouTube or online videos without frequent buffering. However, I wouldn’t say this is anything different than what I’m used to with Air Canada or WestJet.

Porter Airlines WiFi speed test using Ookla.
Porter Airlines WiFi speed test: 22.57 Mbps download, 0.84 Mbps upload.

The in-flight entertainment was a decent enough offering but did have a few quirks. My significant other noted that shows had only half seasons available. For example, for Schitt’s Creek only the second half of the sixth season was available.

Porter Airlines Compared to Other Canadian Carriers

Based on my single-flight experience, I’d rank Porter Airlines above WestJet but below Air Canada. Given the same ticket cost on the same route, I personally would choose Porter ahead of WestJet.  

✔ Included 
$ Available for a fee
PorterClassic Basic WestJet UltraBasicAir Canada Economy BasicPorterClassic StandardWestJet EconoAir Canada Economy Standard
Personal item
Carry-on bag
Checked bags$$$$$$
Changes$$$
Cancellations$$$
Seat Selection$$$$$$
Inflight alcoholic beverages (non-premium)$$$$
Inflight WiFi$$$$

In the above table, I compared the Basic and Standard economy fares of WestJet, Air Canada, and Porter Airlines. 

Related Articles:

When you break it down like this, the differences between the airline fare classes are rather minute. At both levels, Porter wins on inflight alcoholic beverages and inflight WiFi. However, a $5 can of beer and $20 WiFi should be pretty inconsequential to anyone’s airline choice. And aside from that, the fares are nearly identical at the standard level. At the Basic level, Air Canada wins by including a carry-on bag. 

In my mind, the main factors to consider in making your choice between these airlines are: the ticket cost, the 2×2 seating arrangement, and reliability. On the latter, I simply trust Air Canada (and also now Porter based on their CTA track record) more than WestJet to get me to my destination on time. 

Is It Worth Booking a Flight on Porter Airlines?

If my experience is to be considered the norm for Porter, then yes I would say it can absolutely be worth flying Porter Airlines. I would particularly emphasize that for shorter jaunts domestically in Canada, Porter is a great option. I’m also optimistic that Porter Air can be a great option for time-dependent itineraries such as a connecting flight or positioning flight

For longer trips across Canada or to the Western USA however, I would seek a greater level of comfort. Whether that’s in Air Canada business class, or even a PorterReserve Fare with larger seats, is for you to decide.

Conclusion

Porter Air is an up-and-coming airline that aims to offer an elevated economy experience at regular economy pricing. In my experience on Porter Airlines PorterClassic Standard fare, the offering was fairly typical of other economy flights in Canada on WestJet and Air Canada. The main differentiator for Porter is its 2-2 seating arrangement with no middle row, and included complimentary WiFi and alcoholic beverages. 

Having now flown Porter Airlines, I believe that even without these differentiators, Porter is a great third choice in the Canadian market. The additional competition is nothing but a positive for an industry lacking thereof. I am definitely looking to fly Porter again in the future, perhaps this time in Porter Reserve seats!

Frequently Asked Questions

Porter Airlines, or ‘Porter’ is a Canadian airline headquartered at Billy Bishop Airport in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. It started as a small regional airline in 2006 and has since expanded and even flies some routes out of Toronto Pearson Airport today.

Porter flies exclusively with Canadian-built De Havilland Canada DHC-8-400 turboprop aircraft and Embraer E195-E2 jet aircraft.

Yes, Porter Airlines has a loyalty program called VIPorter.

Porter Airlines flies a number of routes from Toronto all over Canada and the United States. They skew heavily towards Eastern Canadian destinations, however.

You can view their current map of routes here.

Porter Airlines is owned by Porter Aviation Holdings, formerly known as REGCO Holdings Inc, which is controlled by the Deluce aviation family, including Robert, brother Peter, and son Michael.

Porter Airlines is safe. Porter is certified as a 4-star airline by Skytrax and has a spotless safety record.

Reed Sutton

Reed Sutton

Founder at Frugal Flyer
Reed is addicted to the art of earning and redeeming travel points, and frequently pairs his trips with his other hobby: photography. Through Frugal Flyer, Reed aims to distill some of the complex and esoteric points strategies into digestible information. Furthermore, he hopes to use his technical expertise to develop invaluable applications and tools for the travel community.

Previous

Using US Cards for Canadian Purchases: Nice Price or No Dice?

The Complete Guide to Marriott Bonvoy Gold Elite Status

Next

Leave a Comment

All comments are moderated according to our comment policy. Your email address will NOT be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.